Great Tips For Handling Criticism
Every time you try to do something new or different, you are bound to come across some form of criticism. Whether it be family or friends, your blogging network, or your commentors or fellow forum members – it will come.
Hopefully you would have noticed the new theme design I have for this blog. Well a couple of days ago, after it was all uploaded and ready, I decided to ask for some feedback off a couple of forums. Just simple questions like, ‘What do you like about the design?’ What don’t you like?’ etc etc.
I knew this would open up the floodgates for people to tell me exactly what they thought. I knew some of their points would be positive and some negative, but thats ok because you need the negatives to know which areas to work on, right?
That may be easy to say when you have not put yourself in that situation, but anyone who has opened themselves or their projects up for feedback will know that the negative feedback is hard to take. It often feels like whenever says there is something wrong with your project or design that it is a personal attack on you, telling you that you are are incompetent and going to fail.
Now we know thats not how they mean to portray themselves, but it is how we take it.
Here are three things that I have found help me take criticism on board – without taking offense!
1. Realize That They Are Not Emotionally Attached
Your project is like a baby to you. It is part of you and you couldn’t be prouder of it. But you have to remember that it is YOUR baby, not anyone else’s. That means that they do not have the same emotions connected to the project as you do, so when they speak their opinions they are just telling you what they think. They are not having a go at your project or you. You asked for their opinion and they gave it – and probably haven’t thought of your project since. so when reading and taking in their constructive criticism, leave your emotions at the door and try to look at your project through their eyes.
2. The Majority Of People Want You To Succeed
The thing I have found when asking for feedback on a design or project is that everyone seems to be so supportive and helpful, and you can tell that they want you to do well. their feedback usually consists of the sandwich approach to feed back (positive, negative then positive) and they do this because they don’t want to offend you.
I know when I give feedback to others I can usually see potential in any project, but that doesn’t mean that I don’t let them know of things that I think could be approved. I mean if I don’t tell you something that I think will stop your projects success then you have to wonder if I even care if you succeed! So see constructive feedback as a positive, from the view that your reviewers want to see your project become the best it can be!
3. Don’t Listen To The Rest
This one is simple. If you can tell they don’t care about your project and are just trying to act all tough by taking unnecessary stabs at your project – just ignore them. Totally ignore them. Their comments do not deserve the courtesy of a reply and don’t give them the pleasure of a moment in your thoughts. Just offload it and focus on fixing the things that others (who do care) have kindly pointed out.
If you are looking to make sure your blog Stands Out from the crowd and is successful, consider subscribing to our feed or email updates to make sure you don’t miss a thing!





9 Responses
5.26.2008
I love the new site, and this is a great post. It can be hard taking criticism. With that said I’m about to give you more, since you obviously can take it :) Average is spelled wrong on your header, unless that’s meant to be spelled wrong… Also the font for Stand Out doesn’t seem to fit with the rest of the fonts your using, or with the theme of your page. Honestly though, your posts have been really good. I followed thomassinfield.com for a while.
5.26.2008
Thanks for that. I hadn’t even noticed the misspell!
I can see what you mean about the font, but I will leave it as is for a while just cause I don’t really have time to find a new one.
I appreciate the honest feedback!
5.30.2008
Great point! It’s true, many ask for opinions but aren’t really ready for them. Like you said, when we start a project, and spend all hours of the night tweaking every little piece, it can be tuff to take the negative feedback.
I too notice that there seems to be an unspoken connection amongst most bloggers, and they generally want to see each other do well.
It’s much easier to approach and befriend a blogger, than many other areas in life. I’ve found most to be very helpful, and honest.
You can’t just walk up to many professionals and ask them how they do what they do and get a real response. However, among the blogsphere, I’ve seen it happen on more than one occasion.
That said, we have to know how to take the critique, and also learn how to properly give it.
Understanding this helps make the blogging community that much more enjoyable for everyone.
see ya
5.31.2008
very good things to keep in mind when asking for advice…here’s another one: just because someone says you should change something or don’t like something, you don’t have to change it, it’s your site not their’s. Be more like a duck with water and just let it roll off your back.
Since we are handing out criticism, it looks like some proofreading is needed in the “Subscribe to this feed” mention at the end of each post:
your blog Stands Out front he crowd
Keep up the good work!
5.31.2008
That is a great point nick. It is your website so you don’t have to do what they say. Thanks for letting me know about the typo, I have been doing these manually at the moment, but just found a great plugin which will automate the ‘Subscribe’ section.
9.21.2008
This is a great topic for all bloggers. We will always get some form or criticism at one time or another. It’s good to be prepared to take it in such a way that you don’t let it knock you off track with your goals and vision for your blog. Thanks for sharing your great advice!
“Motivate Thyself”s last blog post..Your Dreams Are Only As Atainable As Your Resolve Is Unshakable
11.13.2008
You really got a nice post. Criticism is normal. We surely have it in most things we do. Is it in you on how to accept it. Positive or negative. If you take criticism in negative way, you lose. Look at it in positive way. Observe your mistakes to improve them.
Thank you
Diana Ruperts last blog post..5 Best Method to Lose Weight
3.14.2009
I must say, I could not agree with you in 100%, but it’s just my IMHO, which indeed could be very wrong.
p.s. You have an awesome template . Where did you find it?